So just received two of these and thought this would be the answer, but there are a couple of flaws that I can't overlook
So thought I'd mention it here for other people who are looking at a gamepad.
The first flaw I noticed when getting them out of the box is the seriously short cable, I'm thinking this was designed for sitting next to a wedge case and even then not long enough.
My other joysticks I have are two to three times longer and give you some breathing room, but with these gamepads I have to sit straight up and very close I can't lean back.
The button labelled fire isn't that comfortable and is raised higher than the rest and doesn't feel natural (maybe I'm too use to xbox 360 controllers which just feel right).
The autofire fire button is okay, but can't get the turbo autofire to work. (Was playing gauntlet ][) so will hold my verdict on that until I've tried afew more games.
The gamepad feels okay in the hand, and is actually a good size. The D-Pad is okay seems to have positive feedback and clicks a little at first.
After 45 minutes or so I think I might go back to a joystick or the Amiga -> PSX adapter combo.
For the price I guess I can't complain and for that I give it a 3 out 5. With an extra .5 for the random colours on the buttons on every controller :-)